Get Involved

Receive the Newsletter

Enjoying our resources? Receive our monthly newsletter and more from BioLogos, tailored to your interests!

Join Now

Donate to BioLogos!

BioLogos relies on grassroots donors like you to help sustain our mission. Make a donation today, or contact donorsupport@biologos.org with donation related questions.

Give Now


BioLogos Voices is a speakers bureau featuring top scholars and communicators in the BioLogos community. Book a speaker for your next event!

Learn More
See All Events


Join the online community! We welcome you to be a part of the growing group of people who are seeing science as the study of God’s creation while upholding the authority of the Bible!

Join Now
About BioLogos

About Us

Our Mission
Our History
What We Believe
Annual Reports
Endorsements


What We Do

Conferences & Events
Speakers Bureau
Language of God Podcast
Insights Video Series
INTEGRATE Curriculum
BioLogos.org Resources


Our Team

Staff
Board of Directors
Advisory Council
Francis Collins
Careers

ForumsGive
https://biologos.org/common-questions/how-was-the-genesis-account-of-creation-interpreted-before-darwin
Browse Common Questions

Biblical Interpretation

How should we interpret the Genesis flood account?

How long are the days of Genesis 1?

How should we interpret the Bible?

See All
Christianity & Science

What is Evolutionary Creation?

Should Christians get vaccinated?

Should We Trust Science?

Are science and Christianity at war?

See All
Scientific Evidence

What does the fossil record show?

What is the genetic evidence for human evolution?

Does the Cambrian Explosion pose a challenge to evolution?

See All
God's Relationship to Creation

Why should Christians care for creation?

What do “fine-tuning” and the “multiverse” say about God?

What created God?

See All
Human Origins

Did death occur before the Fall?

How could humans have evolved and still be in the “Image of God”?

Were Adam and Eve historical figures?

See All
Explore Faith & Science Resources

Get Started

Use the links below to browse content carefully curated for BioLogos beginners.

Common Questions
Insights Videos
Language of God Podcast
Integrate Curriculum
Resource Centers
Impact Stories
Recommended Books


Featured People
Francis CollinsFrancis Collins
Katharine HayhoeKatharine Hayhoe
N.T. WrightN.T. Wright
Deborah HaarsmaDeborah Haarsma
Praveen SethupathyPraveen Sethupathy

Resource Centers

K-12 Educators
Pastors
Youth Ministry
Campus Ministry
Small Groups


Explore All Topics

Bible
Science
Theology & Philosophy
Church & Culture
Views on Creation


By Type

Common Questions
Articles
Series
Videos
Podcast Episodes
Audio
Books
Impact Stories

What are you looking for?

  • Forums
  • Give
Common Question
  • Common Questions
  • How was the Genesis account of creation interpreted before Darwin?

How was the Genesis account of creation interpreted before Darwin?

  • Biblical Interpretation
  • Genesis & Creation
  • History

Introduction

Many people assume that Darwin’s theory must have shaken the foundations of the Christian faith because of the stark difference between evolution and the idea of a six-day creation. In truth, the literal six-day interpretation of Genesis 1–2 was not the only perspective espoused by Christian thinkers prior to the publication of The Origin of Species in 1859. The works of many early Christian theologians and philosophers reveal an interpretation of Genesis compatible with Darwin’s theory.

Early Christian Thought

Origen, a third-century philosopher and theologian from Alexandria, Egypt—one of the great intellectual centers of the ancient world—provides an example of early Christian thought on creation.

Best known for On First Principles and Against Celsus, Origen presented the main doctrines of Christianity and defended them against pagan accusations. Origen opposed the idea that the creation story should be interpreted as a literal and historical account of how God created the world. There were other voices before Origen who advocated more symbolic interpretations of the creation story. Origen’s views were also influential for other early church thinkers who came after him.1

St. Augustine of Hippo, a bishop in North Africa during the early fifth century, was another central figure of the period. Although he is widely known for Confessions, Augustine authored dozens of other works, several of which focus on Genesis 1–2.2 In The Literal Meaning of Genesis, Augustine argues that the first two chapters of Genesis are written to suit the understanding of the people at that time.3 In order to communicate in a way that all people could understand, the creation story was told in a simpler, allegorical fashion. Augustine also believed God created the world with the capacity to develop, a view that is harmonious with biological evolution.4

Later Christian Thought

There are many other non-literal interpretations of Genesis 1–2 later in history. St. Thomas Aquinas, a well-known thirteenth-century philosopher and theologian, was particularly interested in the intersection of science and religion and was strongly influenced by Augustine. Aquinas did not fear the possible contradiction between the Genesis creation story and scientific findings.

In Summa Theologica, he responds to the question of whether all six days of creation are actually a description of a single day, a theory Augustine had suggested. Aquinas argues in favor of the view that God created all things to have potential:

On the day on which God created the heaven and the earth, He created also every plant of the field, not, indeed, actually, but “before it sprung up in the earth,” that is, potentially.…All things were not distinguished and adorned together, not from a want of power on God’s part, as requiring time in which to work, but that due order might be observed in the instituting of the world.5

Augustine’s creation perspective can be seen even as late as the eighteenth century—just before Darwin published The Origin of Species—in the works of John Wesley. An Anglican minister and early leader in the Methodist movement, Wesley, like Augustine, thought the scriptures were written in terms suitable for their audience. He writes,

The inspired penman in this history [Genesis] … [wrote] for the Jews first and, calculating his narratives for the infant state of the church, describes things by their outward sensible appearances, and leaves us, by further discoveries of the divine light, to be led into the understanding of the mysteries couched under them.6

Wesley also argues the scriptures “were written not to gratify our curiosity [of the details] but to lead us to God.”7

In the nineteenth century, Princeton Theological Seminary was known for its staunch defense of conservative Calvinism and the absolute authority of Scripture. Perhaps the most noted Princeton theologian of that era, B. B. Warfield, accepted evolution as giving the proper scientific account of human origins. He believed that hearing God’s voice in Scripture and the findings of solid scientific work were not at odds. As historian Mark Noll puts it, “B. B. Warfield, the ablest modern defender of the theologically conservative doctrine of the inerrancy of the Bible, was also an evolutionist.”8

Conclusion

The history of Christian thought has not been consistently dominated by proponents of a literal interpretation of Genesis. The discoveries of modern science should neither be seen as the instigator of some abandonment of trust in Scripture, nor as contradictory to Scripture, but as guideposts toward a proper understanding of Scripture’s meaning.

Augustine offers this advice:

In matters that are so obscure and far beyond our vision, we find in Holy Scripture passages which can be interpreted in very different ways without prejudice to the faith we have received. In such cases, we should not rush in headlong and so firmly take our stand on one side that, if further progress in the search of truth justly undermines this position, we too fall with it. That would be to battle not for the teaching of Holy Scripture but for our own, wishing its teaching to conform to ours, whereas we ought to wish ours to conform to that of Sacred Scripture.9


  1. Peter C. Bouteneff, Beginnings: Ancient Christian Readings of the Biblical Creation Narratives(Grand Rapids, MI: Baker, 2008).
  2. Gillian Clark, Augustine: The Confessions (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1993).
  3. Bishop of Hippo Saint Augustine, The Literal Meaning of Genesis, Ancient Christian Writers, no. 41 (New York: Newman Press, 1982).
  4. For a further discussion of Augustine’s perspective on creation, see chapter 6 of Francis Collins’ The Language of God: A Scientist Presents Evidence for Belief (New York: Free Press, 2006), as well as chapters 8 and 15 of Alister McGrath’s A Fine-Tuned Universe: The Quest for God in Science and Theology (Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press, 2009).
  5. St. Thomas Aquinas, “Question 74: All the Seven Days in Common,” in The Summa Theologica of St. Thomas Aquinas, 2nd ed., trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (London: Burns Oates and Washbourne, 1920). Also available online at “Summa Theologica,” New Advent (accessed Oct 21, 2011).
  6. John Wesley, Wesley’s Notes on the Bible (Grand Rapids, MI: Francis Asbury Press, 1987), 22, quoted in Falk, Coming to Peace, 35. Also available online at John Wesley, “John Wesley’s Notes on the Bible,” Wesley Center Online (accessed Oct 21, 2011).
  7. John Wesley, A Survey of the Wisdom of God in the Creation: or, A Compendium of Natural Philosophy, 3rd ed. (London: J. Fry, 1777), 2:463, quoted in Falk, Coming to Peace, 35.
  8. Mark A. Noll and David N. Livingston, eds., B. B. Warfield: Evolution, Science, and Scripture (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2000), 14.
  9. Augustine, The Literal Meaning of Genesis, 41.

Last updated on January 18, 2019

01/06

Related Questions

Did we help answer your question? Try these related questions for more:

All Questions
  • Noah's Ark
    Common Question

    Is Genesis real history?

    We believe Genesis is a true account that, like other ancient narratives, uses vivid imagery to describe past events. It is silent on the scientific questions we might wish it to answer.

  • How should Christians read the Bible?
    Common Question

    How should we interpret the Bible?

    Clues to the original intended meaning can be found in the style of language, the genre of literature, the original audience, and the historical and cultural context.

  • Death and the Fall
    Common Question

    Did death occur before the Fall?

    Humans appear very late in the history of life. The fossil record clearly shows that many creatures died before humans appeared.

  • Noah's Ark
    Common Question

    How should we interpret the Genesis flood account?

    The Flood story proclaims God’s grace and love for his people.

  • Biblical Inerrancy and Creation
    Common Question

    Is Evolutionary Creation compatible with biblical inerrancy?

    Is it possible to accept both biblical inerrancy and an evolutionary understanding of God’s creation?

  • How long are the days of Genesis 1?
    Common Question

    How long are the days of Genesis 1?

    The seven-day pattern in Genesis 1 is a literary device that serves the theological purposes of the author, rather than revealing information about the chronology of natural history.

  • Noah's Ark
    Common Question

    Is Genesis real history?

    We believe Genesis is a true account that, like other ancient narratives, uses vivid imagery to describe past events. It is silent on the scientific questions we might wish it to answer.

  • How should Christians read the Bible?
    Common Question

    How should we interpret the Bible?

    Clues to the original intended meaning can be found in the style of language, the genre of literature, the original audience, and the historical and cultural context.

  • Death and the Fall
    Common Question

    Did death occur before the Fall?

    Humans appear very late in the history of life. The fossil record clearly shows that many creatures died before humans appeared.

  • Noah's Ark
    Common Question

    How should we interpret the Genesis flood account?

    The Flood story proclaims God’s grace and love for his people.

  • Biblical Inerrancy and Creation
    Common Question

    Is Evolutionary Creation compatible with biblical inerrancy?

    Is it possible to accept both biblical inerrancy and an evolutionary understanding of God’s creation?

  • How long are the days of Genesis 1?
    Common Question

    How long are the days of Genesis 1?

    The seven-day pattern in Genesis 1 is a literary device that serves the theological purposes of the author, rather than revealing information about the chronology of natural history.

  • Noah's Ark
    Common Question

    Is Genesis real history?

    We believe Genesis is a true account that, like other ancient narratives, uses vivid imagery to describe past events. It is silent on the scientific questions we might wish it to answer.

  • How should Christians read the Bible?
    Common Question

    How should we interpret the Bible?

    Clues to the original intended meaning can be found in the style of language, the genre of literature, the original audience, and the historical and cultural context.

  • Death and the Fall
    Common Question

    Did death occur before the Fall?

    Humans appear very late in the history of life. The fossil record clearly shows that many creatures died before humans appeared.

  • 01/06

    Related Resources

    If you enjoyed reading this Common Question, we recommend you check out the following:

    All Resources
  • you belong sign
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest Jemar Tisby 

    Jemar Tisby | Splendiferous Wondrous Differences

    Jemar Tisby joins us to talk about the church’s complicity in racism and what we can do about it.

  • bibles in pew
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest Phil Vischer 

    Phil Vischer | Being Evangelical

    As a thoughtful voice in the evangelical community, Phil Vischer's dedication to a truth-seeking and faith centered evangelicalism is an inspiring, and perhaps challenging, model for us all.

  • Reading Genesis on iPhone
    Article
    • By Gregg Davidson 
    • and Ken Turner 

    The Many Layers of Genesis 1

    In this excerpt from their new book, geologist Gregg Davidson and theologian Ken Turner shine a spotlight on Genesis One as theologically rich literature first and foremost.

  • cave with light
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest Willie James Jennings 

    Willie James Jennings | Hollow Places, Hallowed Places

    Jennings helps us to look back into history at a time when colonialist settlers came into contact with new land and new people and found in their theology a justification to bring order to the world they found.

  • Lighting over water
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest Jonathan A. Moo 

    Jonathan Moo | Revelation and Radical Faithfulness

    How should Christians respond to the bleak picture that is sometimes painted of the world?

  • figure coming out of fog
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest N.T. Wright 

    N.T. Wright | The Point of Resurrection

    New Testament scholar N.T. Wright talks about the resurrection: this miraculous, earth shattering event which changed the course of history, and the truth of Easter morning.

  • you belong sign
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest Jemar Tisby 

    Jemar Tisby | Splendiferous Wondrous Differences

    Jemar Tisby joins us to talk about the church’s complicity in racism and what we can do about it.

  • bibles in pew
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest Phil Vischer 

    Phil Vischer | Being Evangelical

    As a thoughtful voice in the evangelical community, Phil Vischer's dedication to a truth-seeking and faith centered evangelicalism is an inspiring, and perhaps challenging, model for us all.

  • Reading Genesis on iPhone
    Article
    • By Gregg Davidson 
    • and Ken Turner 

    The Many Layers of Genesis 1

    In this excerpt from their new book, geologist Gregg Davidson and theologian Ken Turner shine a spotlight on Genesis One as theologically rich literature first and foremost.

  • cave with light
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest Willie James Jennings 

    Willie James Jennings | Hollow Places, Hallowed Places

    Jennings helps us to look back into history at a time when colonialist settlers came into contact with new land and new people and found in their theology a justification to bring order to the world they found.

  • Lighting over water
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest Jonathan A. Moo 

    Jonathan Moo | Revelation and Radical Faithfulness

    How should Christians respond to the bleak picture that is sometimes painted of the world?

  • figure coming out of fog
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest N.T. Wright 

    N.T. Wright | The Point of Resurrection

    New Testament scholar N.T. Wright talks about the resurrection: this miraculous, earth shattering event which changed the course of history, and the truth of Easter morning.

  • you belong sign
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest Jemar Tisby 

    Jemar Tisby | Splendiferous Wondrous Differences

    Jemar Tisby joins us to talk about the church’s complicity in racism and what we can do about it.

  • bibles in pew
    Podcast Episode
    Featuring guest Phil Vischer 

    Phil Vischer | Being Evangelical

    As a thoughtful voice in the evangelical community, Phil Vischer's dedication to a truth-seeking and faith centered evangelicalism is an inspiring, and perhaps challenging, model for us all.

  • Reading Genesis on iPhone
    Article
    • By Gregg Davidson 
    • and Ken Turner 

    The Many Layers of Genesis 1

    In this excerpt from their new book, geologist Gregg Davidson and theologian Ken Turner shine a spotlight on Genesis One as theologically rich literature first and foremost.

  • Common Questions

    Resources

    Christianity and Science
    Scientific Evidence
    Biblical Interpretation
    God’s Relationship to Creation
    Human Origins

    Getting Started
    Common Questions
    Resource Centers
    BioLogos Basics Videos
    Language of God Podcast
    Impact Stories
    Recommended Books

    By Type
    Common Questions
    Articles
    Series
    Videos
    Podcast Episodes
    Audio
    Books
    Impact Stories

    By Topic
    Bible
    Science
    Theology & Philosophy
    Church & Culture
    Views on Creation

    Resources by Audience
    Pastors
    K-12 Educators
    Small Groups
    Youth Ministry
    Campus Ministry

    Get BioLogos Resources


    About Us

    Our Mission
    Our History
    What We Believe
    Annual Reports
    Endorsements

    Get Involved

    Open Forum
    Homeschool Forum
    Attend an Event
    Donate

    What We Do

    BioLogos Conferences
    Resource Centers
    Events
    BioLogos Voices (Speaker’s Bureau)
    Language of God Podcast
    INTEGRATE Curriculum

    Social Media

    BioLogos on Instagram BioLogos on YouTube BioLogos on Twitter BioLogos on Facebook

    © BioLogos 2019  Terms of Use   Privacy   Contact Us   RSS

    It looks like your cart is empty!

    Subtotal: $0.00

    Sign up or log in to continue checkoutBrowse All Units